Dark sweet pitted cherries rewards a little know-how: how to choose them, cook them, store them, and substitute in a pinch. Browse 25 recipes to cook with them.
Dark sweet pitted cherries are the canned or frozen version of Bing-type cherries: deep burgundy, mild, and sweet, with the stones already removed. They're the dark, glossy cherries that anchor Black Forest cake and cherry pie filling, sold packed in light syrup or juice, or frozen loose in a bag.
The "sweet" in the name matters. These are not the bright, mouth-puckering Montmorency cherries used in classic tart cherry pie.
Dark sweet cherries are low in acid and gentle in flavor, so most recipes that use them lean on the cherry color and soft texture more than on a sharp punch.
Buying them pitted and preserved is mostly about convenience. Fresh sweet cherries have a short summer window and need pitting by hand, while a can or freezer bag is ready year-round.
Their home turf is dessert. Folded into a chocolate batter or layered with cream, they carry Black Forest Cherry Cheesecake and Black Forest Chocolate Fudge Cake, and they sink into the middle of Cherry Chocolate Self-Saucing Pudding. Cherry and chocolate is the pairing these cherries were made for.
They also bake into bars and cakes as a ready fruit layer, the cherry ribbon in Whole Wheat Cherry Cream Cheese Bars and Almond Cherry Bundt Cake, or a soft filling for Cherry Filling for Pierogies.
Warmed with a little sugar and a thickener, they turn into a quick sauce in minutes. Cherry Rum Sauce and Best Cherries Jubilee Ice Cream Pie both spoon warm dark cherries over ice cream, and the same sauce loves cheesecake or pancakes.
Don't overlook the savory side. Their sweetness plays against rich meat, so Cherry Orange Chicken and a cherry-spiked Cumberland sauce for ham both use dark cherries as a glaze.
Dark cherries have natural friends. Chocolate, almond, vanilla, orange, and warm cinnamon all flatter them, and a splash of kirsch or rum deepens the flavor. A pinch of acid, lemon juice or a little of the tart cherry's bite, keeps them from tasting one-note.
The biggest mistake is ignoring the packing liquid. Canned cherries come swimming in sweet syrup or juice, so drain them well and account for that extra sugar and water, or your filling turns soupy and cloying.
The second mistake is skipping a thickener. Cherries release a lot of juice as they heat, so a sauce or pie filling needs cornstarch, about 1 tablespoon per cup of fruit and liquid, or it stays watery and won't set.
One more: frozen cherries weep as they thaw. Drain that liquid or fold them in still frozen so your batter doesn't turn pink and wet.
The cleanest swap is fresh sweet cherries, pitted, when they're in season. Use them weight for weight and add a splash of liquid, since they bring no syrup of their own.
Other dark berries fill in well. Pitted Bing or Lambert cherries, frozen dark cherries, even halved black plums echo the color and mild sweetness. For pie filling, a can of cherry pie filling is the ready-made shortcut, though it's already sweetened and thickened.
Tart or sour cherries can stand in, but they change the dish; add more sugar to balance the acid. In a sauce or savory glaze, dried cherries simmered in a little water or juice rehydrate into a concentrated, jammy substitute.
Canned dark sweet cherries come packed in syrup or in plain fruit juice. Choose the juice-packed cans, or the lightest syrup you can find, if you want to control the sweetness yourself.
Check that the can lists them as pitted, since a stray pit is a real risk.
An unopened can keeps in the pantry for years; once opened, move leftovers to a covered container and refrigerate, using them within about four days. Frozen cherries last six to twelve months and are best added straight from frozen.
Fresh sweet cherries, if you're starting from those, keep in the refrigerator unwashed for up to a week. Wash and pit them only when you're ready to cook, and a simple cherry pitter or even a sturdy straw pushes the stones out cleanly.
There are 25 recipes that contain this ingredient.
This easy and delicious cherry chocolate self-saucing pudding is gooey, chocolaty and packed with cherry flavors. It will for sure please your sweet tooth.
Cherry cheesecake ice cream blends cream cheese with sweetened condensed milk and chopped dark cherries for a no-cook custard base with bright fruit ribbons. Tastes like frozen cheesecake.
Homemade cherry and raspberry jam with citrus zest and a hint of almond extract. A no-pectin small-batch preserve that captures peak summer fruit in glossy, ruby-red jars.
Vanilla yogurt makes the cake tangy and moist, homemade cherry filling that has strong cherry taste adds extra layer of deliciousness. By using whole wheat flour and canola oil add some fibre and cut down the saturated fat without taking away any yumminess. Enjoy a slice or two with a cup of coffee or tea.
Spiced cherry orange jam with sliced oranges, dark sweet cherries, and a warm cinnamon-clove-allspice infusion. A small-batch preserve for toast, cheese boards, and gift jars.
These decadent cherry cream cheese bars will well satisfy your cravings for something rich and sweet. They are made with whole wheat flour, light cream cheese, homemade cherry pie filling, a small amount of butter and some olive oil. Much healthier but still tastes delicious. Nobody can resist these sweets, the more importantly you don't have to feel guilty about it.
This cheesecake is amazingly chocolatey and delicious. It screams out the cherry flavour. Definitely worth the effort.
This reduced-fat Chicken Jubilee recipe broils chicken until the skin is golden brown and finishes the main dish on the stovetop. It can be prepared ahead, if desired, to save time the next day.
Retro cola Jell-O mold with cream cheese and dark cherries. This fizzy, creamy gelatin dessert comes together in 5 minutes and sets into a wobbly showstopper your potluck crowd will fight over.
Giant oven-puffed pancake (Dutch baby) with lemon, vanilla, and butter, topped with black cherries, sliced almonds, and powdered sugar. A dramatic 30-minute brunch.
Cherries jubilee ice cream pie swirls a brandy-spiked dark cherry sauce through vanilla ice cream in a honey-graham crust, then freezes firm. A make-ahead frozen take on the flaming dessert classic.
A golden, billowy oven-puffed pancake with lemon zest and vanilla, crowned with sweet black cherries, sliced almonds, and a dusting of powdered sugar. Inn-worthy brunch in 40 minutes.
Honey baked ham basted in pineapple juice and brown sugar, served with a glossy ruby Cumberland sauce of port wine, currants, julienned citrus rind, currant jelly, and dark sweet cherries.
This is an very excellent cheesecake, very yuuuuuy.
Coke salad made with cherry Jello, dark sweet cherries, crushed pineapple, pecans, and cola. A retro Southern gelatin salad that belongs at every potluck.
A chilled Scandinavian-style fruit soup simmered with prunes, raisins, apples, cherries, and citrus, thickened with tapioca and finished with grape juice. Serve cold as a refreshing starter or light dessert.
A puffy, golden Dutch baby pancake with lemon zest and vanilla, topped with dark sweet cherries, sliced almonds, and powdered sugar. Dramatic enough to wow a brunch crowd, easy enough for a Tuesday morning.
Whipped cream fruit salad with pineapple, dark cherries, bananas, dates, marshmallows, and chopped nuts. A retro no-cook dessert salad ready in 5 minutes.
Cherry filling for pierogies takes pitted dark sweet cherries and a squeeze of lemon for a fresh fruit filling. Polish dessert dumpling stuffing that comes together in 20 minutes.
Cherry cheese brownies swirled with cream cheese, coconut, almond extract, and dark sweet cherries through a brownie mix batter. A fancy twist on box brownies.
Whole chicken pieces baked in a sticky brown sugar and orange juice glaze, finished with plump dark sweet cherries. A fruity, golden one-pan dinner for eight.
Self-icing Dr. Pepper cherry cake: dark cherries, cherry Jello, and marshmallows layered with a Dr. Pepper-spiked cake mix that bakes into its own glossy topping.
A glossy cherry rum sauce made with dark sweet cherries, rum extract, and a squeeze of lemon. Ready in 20 minutes, it's the finishing touch for ice cream, cheesecake, or crepes.
Black Forest chocolate fudge cake bakes the cherry-and-chocolate classic into a moist bundt, with dark sweet cherries and toasted walnuts running through a deep cocoa crumb. Prune puree keeps it fudgy and light.