Search
by Ingredient

361 surprise recipes

Recipe NOT List Recipe NOT List™ - disabled
placeholder
Seven Layer Salad

Try this delicious salad for dinner and you will be surprised at how much it feeds your hunger!

placeholder
Plum Jam Muffins

Whole wheat muffins with a sweet plum jam center baked until golden. A simple from-scratch breakfast muffin with a fruity surprise in every bite.

placeholder
Pink Pickeled Eggs

This delicious new rendition of pickled eggs is made with beet juice which gives it a surprising new flavor.

placeholder
15 Min Lemon Cheesecake

If you forgot to make dessert, then surprise your family with this scrumptious cheesecake that's sweet to the touch.

placeholder
The Best Darned Grilled Chicken Ever

This recipe blends together a whole bunch of different spices to give the chicken a surprising and unique flavor.

placeholder
Oatmeal Cake & Frosting

Surprise family at the next Thanksgiving dinner with this delicious cake that is sure to make your aunts proud.

placeholder
Easy Cola Beef Pot Roast

Easy cola beef pot roast braised in cola and chicken broth with onion, carrot, and peas. Surprising soda-tenderized beef with a glossy, sweet-savory sauce.

placeholder
Dampfnudeln (Dumplings)

Traditional German Dampfnudeln: soft steamed yeast dumplings stuffed with prunes, drizzled with buttery poppy seed sauce. A cozy Bavarian dessert that's surprisingly simple to make.

placeholder
Mint Molasses Cookies

Molasses cookies with a surprising hit of mint extract, warm cinnamon, ginger, and clove. Crackly sugar-rolled tops and chewy spiced centers.

placeholder
French Cream Almondine

This decadent snack made with milk chocolate and marshmallow cream is perfect for surprising relatives at the next Christmas dinner!

placeholder
Fettuccine with Lentil Sauce

Fettuccine with red lentil sauce simmered with canned tomatoes, garlic, and a surprising pinch of cinnamon. A high-protein, plant-based pasta dinner ready in under an hour.

placeholder
Lemon Kiss Cookies

Lemon almond cookies wrapped around chocolate kisses, dusted with powdered sugar, and drizzled with melted chocolate for a sweet lemon-chocolate surprise.

placeholder
Halloween Spider Cake

Spooky Halloween spider cake shaped from two round layers with black frosting, licorice legs, and gumball eyes. A fun green gelatin surprise hides inside the body.

placeholder
Mrs Fields' Lemon Chocolate Chip Buttons

Mrs Fields-style lemon chocolate chip buttons with lemon extract, ground coriander, and mini chocolate chips. Tiny, soft, pale cookies with a surprising citrus-spice twist.

placeholder
Oh Boy Cookie Cake

Cookies-and-cream bundt cake studded with quartered Oreos and drizzled in a glossy chocolate glaze. A rich, vanilla-based batter with a crunchy cookie surprise in every slice.

placeholder
Chicken Stroganoff

Was pleasantly surprised by the taste of this recipe. Was very good recipe, even without onions or sour cream. Would recommend!!

Showing 161 - 176 of 361 recipes