Search
by Ingredient

71 surprise recipes

by title

Recipe NOT List Recipe NOT List™ - disabled
Surprise Rice
Surprise Rice

Surprise your family with this super simple side dish. This tasty dish is a fusion of fluffy rice and savory cocktail sausages hidden within a non-descript casserole. Drop this on the family dinner table, and once your unsuspecting patrons dig into an otherwise plain-looking rice casserole - boom, surprise!

Chocolate Surprise Cupcakes
Chocolate Surprise Cupcakes

These are really good. Moist chocolate cupcake with near perfect crumb. As you eat the cupcake the experience is punctuated by the surprise.

Banana Surprise Cookies
Banana Surprise Cookies

Banana surprise cookies are soft chewy oatmeal cookies with mashed bananas, brown sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, and your choice of walnuts or chocolate chips. A 30-minute drop cookie.

Halloween Chocolate Surprise Cupcakes
Halloween Chocolate Surprise Cupcakes

These chocolaty and moist cupcakes are filled with cream cheese and chocolate chips filling that adds extra creaminess and chocolaty taste into every bite. Decorate these delicious cupcakes into Halloween spiders, skulls, skeleton, mummies... Whichever way you or your kids love. Being creative and make sure to make a few bunches, they will disappear quickly.

Ultimate Strawberry Surprise Cake
Ultimate Strawberry Surprise Cake

If you love strawberries and love cake you should try this cake. A nice yellow cake with strawberry filling, and cream cheese frosting. ENJOY!

Stuffed Pork Tenderloin with Delicious Surprises
Stuffed Pork Tenderloin with Delicious Surprises

Stuffing, veggies, fancy cheese, bacon and a mouth watering marinade!

Double Chocolate Peanut Butter Surprise Cookies
Double Chocolate Peanut Butter Surprise Cookies

Double Chocolate Peanut Butter Surprise Cookies recipe

placeholder
Oreo Surprise

Oreo Surprise, a no-bake layered icebox dessert: crushed Oreo crust, sweet cream cheese cream, chocolate pudding, and whipped topping, crowned with cookie crumbs. Best made the night before.

placeholder
Surprise Packages

Surprise packages are butter cookies with a chocolate mint wafer hidden inside each one, iced and decorated to look like tiny Christmas presents. A fun holiday baking project.

placeholder
Noodle Surprise

Whole wheat noodle casserole with sauteed mushrooms, sunflower seeds, yogurt, and cheese topped with breadcrumbs. A crunchy, creamy vegetarian bake.

placeholder
Spaghetti Surprise

A layered baked spaghetti casserole with crumbled tofu, cottage cheese, and melty mozzarella in a herb-tomato sauce. The surprise? It's vegetarian and nobody will guess.

placeholder
Salmon Surprise Loaf

Salmon loaf with spinach, dill, and lemon baked into a light, heart-healthy main dish. Budget-friendly canned salmon gets a fresh-tasting upgrade.

placeholder
Neptune's Surprise

Seafood casserole with shrimp, scallops, crab, and oysters in a creamy dill-mayo sauce topped with crushed potato chips. A retro four-shellfish bake with a crunchy golden crust.

placeholder
Blueberry Surprise

A 6-ingredient blueberry dump cake layered with crushed pineapple, white cake mix, and walnuts. No mixing, no bowls. Just layer everything in the pan, drizzle with butter, and bake.

placeholder
Surprise Spareribs

Surprise your spareribs with this simple recipe that uses pickling spices and prepared mustard.

placeholder
Popcorn Surprises

Popcorn surprises made with candy-coated popcorn ground fine and mixed into melted chocolate, then molded or cut into shapes. A unique candy that makes about 50 pieces.

Showing 1 - 16 of 71 recipes