Here's everything worth knowing about instant pudding mix, butterscotch and how to pick it, what it is, how to store it, and what to use instead, plus 13 recipes to cook tonight.

What is instant pudding mix, butterscotch?

Butterscotch instant pudding mix is a boxed powder that sets into a soft, no-cook pudding when whisked with cold milk. Its flavor is the brown-sugar-and-butter note of butterscotch, warmer and more caramel-toned than vanilla and without the chocolate of its more common siblings.

The powder is mostly sugar and modified cornstarch that gels in cold liquid, plus the butterscotch flavoring and a touch of yellow color.

Bakers reach for it as much for that flavor and thickening power as for pudding itself.

How to Use Butterscotch Pudding Mix

The basic pudding is whisking one box into the cold milk on the label, usually about 2 cups, for two minutes until it thickens, then chilling five minutes. That alone becomes a parfait or a pie filling.

Where butterscotch really pulls its weight is as a built-in caramel flavor. Stir the dry powder straight into doughs and batters and it deepens everything toward butterscotch and caramel.

It is the gooey backbone of a Butterscotch Pull Apart and the brown-sugar layer in Mom's Sticky Nut Buns and an Overnight Coffee Cake, where the dry mix is sprinkled over dough and melts into a sticky glaze as it bakes.

It also sets desserts without any oven at all. Folded into the binder, it firms up No Bake Caramel Cookies, and whisked with cream and condensed milk it carries a No-Cook Butterscotch Ice Cream that needs no churning custard.

For a quick poke cake, bake a yellow or spice cake, then pour thin butterscotch pudding into holes poked across the top so it soaks in.

Pairing and Common Mistakes

Butterscotch leans into warm, toasty partners: pecans, walnuts, banana, toffee, coffee, and cinnamon. It is the natural match for spice cakes and pumpkin, which is why it works in pumpkin cupcakes, and it loves a salted finish that cuts its sweetness.

The biggest mistake is using cook-and-serve mix when a recipe calls for instant, or the reverse. Instant sets cold with starch alone; cook-and-serve must be heated to thicken. They are not interchangeable, and swapping them gives you soup or a grainy mess.

The second mistake is over-whisking pudding made with milk. Beat it past the point it thickens and you can break the gel, leaving it loose.

The third is forgetting how sweet the mix already is. When you add it to a dough or batter for flavor, cut back a little on the recipe's sugar so the result is not cloying.

Substitutes

The closest swap is another instant pudding flavor. Vanilla instant pudding plus a tablespoon of brown sugar approximates the butterscotch note in most baked recipes, and caramel instant pudding is even closer where you can find it.

For the pudding itself, a homemade butterscotch can be cooked on the stove from brown sugar, butter, and cornstarch, though that is a cook-and-serve style and will not set cold.

In a baked dish where the mix is there for moisture and a caramel hint, a few tablespoons of dry vanilla mix plus brown sugar covers it.

There is no good no-cook substitute for the cold-set thickening, though. That is the one thing the box does that a homemade version cannot.

Buying and Storage

Find it in the baking aisle near gelatin and cake mixes, usually in small 3 to 4 ounce boxes. Check that the box says instant, not cook-and-serve, since both flavors of butterscotch exist.

Unopened, the dry mix keeps well past its printed date; it is shelf-stable powder, and the date is about flavor, not safety. Store it in a cool, dry cupboard and keep an opened pouch tightly sealed so it does not clump from humidity.

Made-up pudding is perishable. Cover it against a skin forming and refrigerate, where it keeps three to four days.

Quick facts

In Chinese

即时布丁组合，奶油

British (UK) term

Instant pudding mix, butterscotch

en français

pouding instantané, caramel

en español

mezcla de pudín instantáneo, caramelo

Recipes using instant pudding mix, butterscotch

There are 13 recipes that contain this ingredient.

All 13 recipes