Here's everything worth knowing about candy coated chocolate pieces and how to pick them, what they are, how to store them, and what to use instead, plus 15 recipes to cook tonight.
Candy coated chocolate pieces are small chocolate buttons sealed in a thin, hard sugar shell that comes in bright colors. M&M's are the name most people picture, but the generic version sold in bulk and store brands works the same way and costs less.
The shell is the whole point. It keeps the chocolate from melting in your hand and holds its color through the oven.
Most are plain milk chocolate, though peanut and dark versions and a mini size are easy to find. Recipes here use the candy almost interchangeably with the M&M's brand, so treat the two as the same ingredient when you shop.
The shell is what makes these candies a baker's favorite over plain chocolate chips. Stir them into cookie dough and they keep their shape and color instead of bleeding into the crumb, which is why Clover Chip Cookies and Super Cookies lean on them for a speckled, confetti look.
Press a few extra pieces onto the tops of dough balls right before they go in the oven. The ones folded into the center can crack or fade, so the surface candies are what give you that glossy, colorful finish people expect.
They scatter just as well over an unbaked surface. Frosted Christmas Brownies and Easter Basket Cake use them as decoration pressed into wet frosting, and Halloween Chocolate Spiders rely on the candies for eyes and color on no-bake treats.
These play well with peanut butter, oats, pretzels, and salted nuts, where the crisp shell adds crunch against soft or chewy textures. In a trail mix they become the sweet counterweight to all that salt.
The biggest mistake is overbaking. Past about 350°F (175°C) for more than ten or twelve minutes, the sugar shells crack and the dye runs, leaving muddy halos in light-colored dough. Pull cookies a touch early and let carryover heat finish them.
Color bleed gets worse with moisture. If your batter is very wet or you fold the candies in while warm, expect streaking. Cool the dough first, and save the brightest pieces for pressing on top after baking.
For folding into dough, chocolate chips give you the chocolate without the color or crunch. Chopped chocolate bars work too, though both will melt and spread rather than hold their shape.
When the color is the point, reach for another candy-shelled chocolate. A store brand or mini candy-coated pieces match closest, and candy-coated sunflower seeds cover a nut-free crowd.
For pure decoration on frosting, nonpareils or chopped colored candy stand in fine.
Buy them in bulk bags if you bake often. The price per ounce drops well below single-serve packs, and seasonal colors show up around the holidays, from Christmas red and green to Halloween orange and black.
Mini versions distribute better through dough, while standard size reads bolder as a topping.
Stored airtight in a cool, dry cupboard, the candies keep their crunch for many months. Their enemy is humidity, which softens the shell and makes pieces tacky and prone to clumping.
Keep them out of the fridge, where condensation does the same damage. If a bag has gone sticky, it is still safe to eat but will smear in baking.
There are 15 recipes that contain this ingredient.
A delicious blend of crunchy cereal, salty peanuts, and sweet candy-coated chocolate pieces blanketed in a buttery, peanut butter-enriched coating. This snack mix is perfect for any occasion you have guests to entertain; everyone will enjoy it. The recipe can be easily made in the oven or microwave and is perfect for sharing with friends and family.
This is a fun recipe for you to make with your kids, and your kids will love these chocolate coated spiders!!
Giant flourless peanut butter oatmeal cookies loaded with chocolate chips and candy pieces. Each cookie uses a third cup of dough for bakery-sized results with chewy centers.
Easter basket cake built from stacked round layers with green-tinted coconut grass, a foil-ribbon handle, and candy-studded sides. A showstopping family Easter dessert kids help decorate.
Oversized peanut butter pizza cookies topped with chocolate frosting, cashews, candy pieces, coconut, gumdrops, and a white chocolate drizzle. A fun decorating project for kids.
Cat-shaped chocolate chip cookies with pecan ears, pretzel whiskers, and candy eyes. A fun baking project kids will love decorating and eating.
Brown sugar chocolate chip cookies topped with red candy-coated chocolate pieces before baking. Shortening-based for chewy centers with a 5-7 minute bake time that keeps them soft.
Gingerbread house cake: a warmly spiced two-layer gingerbread cake filled with cream cheese frosting and candy, then decorated like a gingerbread house. All the festive fun without the structural engineering.
Holiday double chocolate brownies topped with candy-coated chocolate pieces baked into the surface. A fudgy cocoa brownie with a festive, colorful crunch on top.
Chewy brown sugar cookies loaded with green candy-coated chocolate pieces. A fun, festive cookie for St. Patrick's Day baking that makes 3 dozen in just 30 minutes.
Buttery sugar cookies studded with colorful candy-coated chocolate pieces, slightly flattened and baked until golden at the edges. Kids absolutely love these sparkly, chewy gems.
Easter chip cookies loaded with pastel candy-coated chocolate pieces in a chewy brown sugar dough. Festive, colorful drop cookies the kids will love decorating Easter baskets with.
Loaded drop cookies packed with chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, coconut, oatmeal, nuts, and candy-coated chocolates on top. These kitchen sink cookies have everything but the sink.
Frosted Christmas brownies baked in a pizza pan, topped with vanilla buttercream and decorated with piped holly leaves and red candy berries. A festive holiday dessert.
These bars have been a family favorite for Mary Wilhelm of Sparta for decades.