Wondering what to do with frozen yogurt? This guide covers how to pick it, cook it, store it, and swap it, plus 10 recipes to put it to work.
Frozen yogurt is cultured yogurt churned and frozen into a dessert. It sits between ice cream and sorbet: creamier than a fruit ice, lighter than ice cream, and carrying the same lactic tang that sets yogurt apart.
That tang is the signature. Where ice cream tastes purely sweet, frozen yogurt finishes with a clean, slightly sour edge.
The big difference is fat. Ice cream leans on cream and egg yolks for richness, while frozen yogurt is built mostly on yogurt or milk, so it carries far less butterfat.
Less fat is why it tastes lighter. It is also why texture takes more care, since fat is what keeps ice cream scoopable, and without much of it frozen yogurt freezes harder and can turn icy.
The fix is sugar and churning. Sugar lowers the freezing point so fewer big ice crystals form, and constant churning whips in air and keeps the crystals tiny, which is what gives you a smooth, soft scoop.
Churn a sweetened yogurt base in an ice cream maker and you get soft-serve straight from the machine, the loose, swirlable texture of Buttermilk Custard Vanilla Frozen Yogurt.
Want it firmer? Pack it into a tub and freeze a few more hours.
Fruit and sauce do the rest. It is the cool base scooped into a Raspberry & Mango Sundae, or left to melt over a warm Ginger Apple Crisp.
Building the base on Greek yogurt gives a thicker, tangier result with more protein and less iciness, since the strained yogurt brings less water to freeze.
Tubs vary a lot, so read the label. Low-fat and non-fat versions lean hard on sugar to stay smooth, so a "healthier" froyo can carry as much sugar as ice cream.
For the probiotic angle, check for live and active cultures. Freezing pauses the bacteria but plenty survive, though some commercial froyo is heat-treated and has none.
Keep it frozen at 0°F (-18°C) and press plastic wrap against the surface to block ice crystals and freezer burn. Homemade froyo has no stabilizers, so it freezes rock-hard; let it sit out ten minutes before scooping.
See yogurt for the cultured base it starts from.
There are 10 recipes that contain this ingredient.
Chocolate Pancakes with Chocolate-Raspberry Sauce recipe
Baked apple halves stuffed with brandy-soaked dried cherries and drizzled with a maple caramel sauce. Served warm with vanilla frozen yogurt for an elegant fall dessert.
Light fudge brownie sundae with a self-saucing chocolate cake baked over a built-in fudge layer, topped with frozen yogurt. A reduced-fat dessert that uses applesauce in place of butter.
No-bake chocolate banana split pie with a chocolate graham cracker crust, frozen yogurt filling, sliced bananas, and whipped topping. A lighter frozen dessert with banana split flavor.
Barefoot and Pregnant non-alcoholic mocktail blends cappuccino frozen yogurt with raspberry daiquiri mix, sparkling water, and a splash of mint syrup. A creamy, layered alcohol-free drink with grown-up flavor.
Cinnamon apple bundt cake made with whole wheat flour, fresh apple slices, walnuts, and apple juice. A lighter oil-based cake dusted with powdered sugar, best served warm.
No-bake peach ice cream cake layered with gingersnap crumbs, toasted almonds, crystallized ginger, peach frozen yogurt, vanilla ice cream, and caramel sauce. Frozen overnight and sliced like a loaf.
Low-calorie ginger apple crisp with a cornflake crumb topping and crystallized ginger. Six apples baked bubbly under a crunchy, spiced streusel in 30 minutes.