Nero Wolfe's Finnan Haddie (Smoked Haddock)
Submitted by revclaus
Classic finnan haddie in cream sauce with hard-cooked eggs, pimiento, and broiled bread crumbs. Inspired by the Nero Wolfe mystery novels, served with anchovy toast.
Straight from the dining table of fiction’s most famous gourmand, this finnan haddie recipe is the kind of old-school, no-shortcuts cooking that Nero Wolfe’s personal chef Fritz Brenner would approve of. Smoked haddock gets soaked to mellow the salt, then poached in milk and water to build a rich, smoky stock.
That poaching liquid becomes the foundation of a proper cream sauce. Butter and flour form the roux, then heavy cream and the reserved fish stock cook down into something thick enough to coat a spoon. A whisper of nutmeg adds warmth without announcing itself.
The assembled casserole is a layered affair: flaked fish folded into the cream sauce, topped with sliced hard-cooked eggs and chopped pimiento for color, then finished with bread crumbs under a hot broiler until golden and bubbling. The anchovy butter toast on the side is not optional; that salty, savory crunch against the creamy fish is what makes this a complete experience.
Kitchen Tips
- Soak the finnan haddie for the full hour; skipping this leaves the fish unpleasantly salty
- Poach gently and let the fish rest in the liquid off the heat so it stays tender and flaky, not rubbery
- Reserve the ¼ cup of sauce before adding the fish so you have a clean layer to pour over the eggs
- Watch the broiler closely at the end; bread crumbs go from golden to burnt in seconds
Variations
- Substitute smoked cod or smoked whiting if finnan haddie is hard to find in your area
- Add a splash of dry sherry to the cream sauce for extra depth
- Top with grated Gruyere cheese along with the bread crumbs for a gratin-style finish
Ingredients
Directions
Soak finnan haddie in water to cover for 1 hour.
Drain and put into a large saucepan, covering with the milk and water.
Bring to a boil, remove from the heat and let stand for 10 to 15 minutes.
When cooled, remove the skin and bones, reserving the stock.
Melt the butter in a heavy- bottomed saucepan.
Stir in the flour and cook over direct low heat until smooth.
Add the cream and 1¼ cups of the reserved stock; continue to cook, stirring occasionally, until the mixture is slightly thickened.
Season with pepper and nutmeg.
When the sauce is thick enough to coat a spoon, remove it from the heat, measure out ¼ cup, and set it aside.
Break the finnan haddie into pieces and fold them into the sauce.
Simmer gently over low heat for a few minutes until the fish is warmed.
Pour the mixture into a shallow casserole; cover with the pimiento and sliced hard-cooked eggs and pour the reserved ¼ cup of sauce over the eggs.
Sprinkle the dish with bread crumbs and place under a hot broiler to brown.
Serve with the anchovy toast.
Comments