Search
by Ingredient

50 haloween cookie recipes

Recipe NOT List Recipe NOT List™ - disabled
placeholder
Cat Poop Cookies

Whole wheat cookies shaped like cat poop, rolled in Grape-Nuts, and served in a litter box. Two dough options: chocolate or gingerbread. The ultimate gross-out Halloween party hit!

placeholder
Blackberry Blackheads^

Buttery thumbprint cookies with a gross-out Halloween twist: pale, tender shortbread rounds dimpled and filled with dark blackberry jam that looks like a 'blackhead.' Easy, funny, and good enough to disappear fast.

Showing 49 - 64 of 50 recipes