Search
by Ingredient

100 substitute butter recipes

Recipe NOT List Recipe NOT List™ - disabled
placeholder
Currant Cake

Old-fashioned currant cake with lemon zest, folded egg whites, and cream of tartar leavening. A light, tender butter cake studded with dried currants. Makes 2 cakes in about an hour.

placeholder
Rolled Oats Cakes

Rolled oats pancakes made with oats, buttermilk, and a touch of maple flavoring for hearty, nutty griddle cakes with more texture than regular pancakes. A filling, wholesome breakfast.

placeholder
Chocolate Popcorn Fudge

Chocolate popcorn fudge: classic stovetop chocolate fudge cooked to soft-ball stage with chopped popped corn folded in for surprise crunch in every creamy square.

placeholder
Black Walnut Cookies

Crisp, buttery slice-and-bake cookies with brown sugar, a hint of nutmeg, and bold black walnut flavoring. Shape the dough into logs, chill overnight, and slice thin for a quick batch of 48.

placeholder
Cream of Lima Bean Soup

Old-fashioned cream of lima bean soup simmered low and slow with butter, paprika, and a touch of cream. Thick, hearty, and full of homestyle comfort in every bowl.

placeholder
Cinnamon Breakfast Cake

Old-fashioned cinnamon breakfast cake with brown sugar, raisins, and a buttery cinnamon-sugar crust. Ready in 30 minutes with simple pantry staples.

placeholder
Honey Drops

Honey drops candy boils pure honey with butter and a splash of lemon to hard ball stage, then pulls into chewy white taffy with a porous, melt-on-the-tongue texture.

placeholder
Brown Sugar Bread

Brown sugar bread with a cinnamon-brown sugar topping baked until golden. A quick bread that needs no yeast, just basic pantry ingredients and 25 minutes in the oven.

placeholder
Classic Cream of Corn Soup

Cream of corn soup builds a classic milk-based bechamel with butter, flour, and minced onion, then folds in sweet corn and celery leaves. A simple, vegetarian comfort soup ready in 40 minutes.

placeholder
Grandma's Icebox Cookies

Old-fashioned icebox cookies with cardamom, cinnamon, lemon juice, and chopped nuts. Slice-and-bake dough that refrigerates overnight or freezes for weeks. Paper-thin and crispy.

placeholder
Corn Muffins with Honey Butter

Corn muffins made with yellow cornmeal, dry milk powder, and a splash of lemon juice served with whipped honey butter. A big-batch recipe that makes two dozen tender muffins.

placeholder
Jumbles # 2

Jumbles are old-fashioned filled sandwich cookies, two rolled rounds enclosing a smear of grape jelly with three peek-a-boo windows cut into the top. Vintage pantry treat.

placeholder
Vegetarian Butter

A vegan butter substitute for spreading on bread and vegetables.

placeholder
Adas Careh (Lentil Butter)

Use a butter substitute and make your toast look vibrant!

placeholder
Tahini Oatmeal Date Cookies with Pecan & Raisin

Tahini Oatmeal Date Cookies with Pecan and Raisin recipe

placeholder
Raisin Puree

Raisin puree fat substitute for baking, made with just raisins, water, and vanilla. Replaces butter or oil 1:1 in cookies, cakes, and brownies while keeping baked goods moist and chewy.

Showing 65 - 80 of 100 recipes